DB Cargo eyes rail freight arm sale amid concern over state subsidy

04.19.2024

German outlets are reporting that Deutsche Bahn may be considering selling its freight arm, DB Cargo, as EU regulators eye the operator amid claims of market distortion.

Losses at the beleaguered German state operator have passed the half-a-billion euro mark and European authorities have become increasingly concerned that the government plugging these losses is proving anti-competitive and distorting the market.

Seeking to avoid sanctions, DB has been seeking a resolution, and Handelsblatt reports general counsel Alexander Gommlich’s claim that DB Cargo’s future was «open».

Citing multiple sources, the German paper suggests nothing is off the table t settle the issue — partial and total sale being considered, despite it still accounting for some 20% of DB’s total traffic.

Other reports have suggested that the EC would be content with the sale of just a minority share.

A spokesperson for Die Gueterbahnen, which represents Germany’s private railroads, told The Loadstar DB Cargo had only survived due to its «below-cost prices», subsidised by the state. Handing over DB Cargo’s rail freight services that compete with other railroads would be «a major step forward for fair competition in rail freight transport» it added.

Private operators have, nonetheless, managed to dent DB Cargo’s dominance, securing some 59% of market share by 2022, with a source noting that, contrary to reports, recent strikes at DB Cargo had not stopped all German rail freight.

Meanwhile, Germany is not alone in being investigated by European authorities for subsidising its national rail operator. France’s Fret SNCF faces being shut down by its parent — the response to which has been less than positive. Criticism — including from the European Parliament — is that the decision was ‘ill thought out’, and there would be little sign of a private company picking up the volume shortfall.

Analytics on topic
Article
01.19.2020
Freight’s role in zero carbon emissions - ERFA
In achieving its green commitments, the European Union is paying more and more attention to the transition to railway transport. Currently, a significant part of the domestic freight traffic is carried out by road transport.
Source: Rail Technology Magazine
Article
06.05.2020
Will China Railway Express boom in 2020?
During the month of December we have celebrated the fifth anniversary of the first cargo train Yiwu-Madrid (China Railway Express). In November of 2014, the Chinese and Spanish Governments both witnessed the longest railway route in the world being born. By then, the company responsible of the initiative, Yixinou, was able to manage one train to one destination. Five years later, we are confident to reach a total number of 500 trains operating to 11 different worldwide destinations departing or arriving in Yiwu, East China’s Zhejiang Province.
Source: Global Times